Fair Value And Equity Method Of Valuing Equity Investments

GAAP gave the option to entities to:

  1. Measure most financial assets and liabilities at fair value, and
  2. Report unrealized gains and losses in earnings

The decision of whether to elect the fair value option is made irrevocably at an election date. The decision is made instrument by instrument

The fair value option need not be applied to all instruments in a single transaction. For eg. it may be applied to some select shares or bonds acquired in a transaction

Fair value option cannot be elected to the following items:

  1. An investment that requires to issue consolidated financial statements
  2. Obligations for post-retirement employee benefits
  3. Financial assets and liabilities under leases
  4. Demand deposit liabilities
  5. Financial instruments at least partly classified in equity

An entity may choose to elect Fair Value Option for an investment in investee where it could have elected to account the investments under the equity method 

Financial Statement Presentation

Balance Sheet 

Assets and liabilities measured using the fair value option are reported in a way that separates their fair values from the carrying amount of similar items measured using another attribute

Income Statement

 Unrealized gains and losses on items measured using the fair value option are recognized as earnings in the income statement

Investments in Equity Securities 

The accounting method for investment in voting stock depends on the presumed influence that the investor has over the investee. The presumed influence is determined based on the ownership interest held 

Percentage Ownership      Presumed Influence      Accounting Method 

<20%                                              Little or none                       Fair Value Method

= 20% <= 50%                           Significant Influence         Equity Method or Fair Value Option

> 50%                                                   Control                              Consolidation

Measurement of an Investment in Equity Securities 

The investment is measured at fair value at each balance sheet date

Unrealized holding gains and losses on the re-measurement of the investment to fair value are reported in the income statement at each subsequent reporting date

Dividends received from investments in equity securities are reported as dividend income in the income statement

Measurement of Investment in Equity Securities without readily determinable fair value 

An entity may elect a measurement alternative for an investment in equity securities without a readily determinable fair value

This alternative is cost minus impairment (if any), plus or minus changes resulting from observable price changes for the identical or similar investment of the same issuer

The entity must reassess at each reporting period whether the fair value of an equity investment is readily determinable

Impairment Test

A qualitative assessment of whether an investment is impaired must be performed at each reporting date

An investment is impaired if the fair value of the investment is lower than its carrying amount

Equity Method 

An investment in common stock enabling the investor to exercise significant influence over the investee should be accounted for by the equity method (assuming no FVO election is made)

An equity method investment is initially recognized at cost. The price paid by an investor to acquire shares in an investee may differ from the underlying book value (i.e. the investee's net assets per its financial statements) it represents

The difference may be on account of

  1. Premium paid (i.e. goodwill) by the investor to acquire the investment
  2. Discrepancies between the investee's recognized net assets at book values and at current fair values
  3. Unrecognized assets in the books of the investee

Equity Method Goodwill 

Goodwill resulting from the acquisition is the difference between the cost of the investment and the investor's equity in the fair value of the investee's net assets

Equity Method goodwill is included in the carrying amount of the equity method investment

Equity method investment is tested for impairment

Applying the Equity Method  

Under the equity method, the investor recognizes in income its share of the investee's earnings or losses in the periods for which they are reported by the investee

Thus, the equity method involves:

  1. Increasing the original cost of the Investment by the investor's pro-rata share of the investee's earnings
  2. Decreasing the original cost of the investment:
    1. By the investor's share of the investee's losses, and
    2. For dividends paid (treated as a return on investment)

Thus, under the equity method the investment account moves as below:

Carrying Value of the Investment (Opening)  

+    Share of Investee's net income (loss)

-      Dividends received

___________________________________

=   Carrying Value of the Investment (Closing)

___________________________________

The investor share of investee losses in excess of the carrying value on investment 

An equity method investment would not be permitted to have a negative balance since the investor enjoys limited liability. When the investment account reaches a zero balance, discontinue the application of the equity method and make only disclosures in the notes.

If the investor later returns to profitability, the investor should ignore its share of earnings until the previously ignored losses have been fully offset

Change to Equity Method - Increase in Level of Ownership  

When significant influence is achieved in stages, the investor applies the equity method prospectively from the moment the significant influence is achieved 

Change from Equity Method 

If an investor can no longer be presumed to exercise significant influence, it ceases to account for the investment using the equity method

If you have found this blog to be useful, you may share with your friends. Thanks!

 

Posted in Business & Finance and tagged , , .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *